Operational Management


4. Seven-Eleven is attempting to duplicate the supply chain structure that has succeeded in Japan in the United States with the introduction of CDCs. What are the pros and cons of this approach? Keep in mind that stores are also replenished by wholesalers and DSD by manufacturer?

There has been useful advantage of Seven-Eleven upon CDC and DSD as the centers allow smoothing of distribution operation to the stores and the provision of better quality and better information on supply and deliveries is available and there was control of the supply chain as achieved. The presence of technology like the adaptation of the POS system can possibly move ahead and do aid the store employment and management situation by freeing up staff time.

Seven-Eleven U.S. has begun introduce the Combined Distribution Center daily delivery of fresh-prepared foods around 2000. By partnering with multiple food companies, the convenience retailer will be able to offer fresh-made-daily and delivered-fresh-daily pastries, gourmet sandwiches, wraps, entrees, as well as other perishable and ready-to-eat foods once a day. This was a challenge because the CDCs are operated by several different third-party partners, and Seven-Eleven felt it did not have effective metrics for comparing performance to a reliable benchmark. This was due to many factors, including different facility sizes, building layouts and the variety of products handled by each CDC.

pros

  • Added choices to customers in perishable consuming. Seven-Eleven can add other specialty items to its selection such as fruit salads, seasonal whole and cut fruit, fresh-squeezed juices and produce from a farmer’s market. The consumers can easily get the fresh perishable products near their house.
  • Daily delivery means just that Seven-Eleven stores can place orders to the CDC and get fresh product by sorting for delivery to stores at every night
  • With the company’s proprietary retail information system, each store can customize its order to provide the exact items the customers in their neighborhood want.
  • Receiving fewer deliveries to your store during the day. In this advantages, the stores no need to waste the time to check through each delivery because all needed products will be set up and combined since the Distribution Centers.
  • Expedite business for local food companies, which can now make one delivery to a central location for distribution to local stores.
  • Reduce the holding Inventory Cost. Stores can order just the amount they sell in a day or two, so they don’t have product sitting around on the shelves. That means that they can guarantee the freshness in the perishable products at Seven-Eleven.
  • The staffs are able to consolidate work and spend more time with your customers, growing your business. As they will check the stock and place the order to the CDC and receive the product at night.
  • The suppliers can delivery in large amount with one full truck load as there has a store big enough to keep the products with the method to keep the product longer and still perish. Cons
  • Much lower density (hence longer distance) of U.S. Seven-Eleven stores. Deliver a few product everyday may using too much cost with the longer distance of each branch. Need to increase density, even though setting up own system only reduce problems by eliminating delivers
  • Increase transportation cost at stores because of increased delivers. As Distribution Centers need to deliver the product everyday with a few amounts in order to keep the freshness of the product.
  • Losing the economics of scale advantages, as Seven-Eleven need to order the product everyday in the fewer amounts.
  • High costs of keeping the products as some products need a specific temperature to keep them

3. What has Seven-Eleven done in its choice of facility location, inventory management, transportation, and information infrastructure to develop capabilities that support its supply chain strategy in Japan?

“Filling in the entire map of Japan is not our priority. Instead, we look for demand where Seven-Eleven stores already exist, based on our fundamental area dominance strategy of concentrating stores in specific areas.” this above statement shown that to ensure that the support of Seven-Eleven Japan’s facility location to its supply chain strategy, Seven-Eleven Japan has based its fundamental network expansion policy on a market dominance strategy.

Wherever Seven-Eleven Japan entries into any new market, it was built around a cluster of 50 – 60 stores supported by a distribution center. The main reason of applying cluster strategy, it is that clustering gave Seven-Eleven Japan a high-density market presence and allowed it to operate an efficient distribution system. There are several benefits of implementing the market-dominance strategy including such as boosting distribution efficiency, improved brand awareness, increasing the system efficiency, enhancing efficiency of franchise support services, improving advertising effectiveness and preventing competitors’ entrance into the dominant area.

For inventory management, what Seven-Eleven Japan had done to develop capability that support its supply chain strategy is to offer its stores a choice from a set of 5,000 stock keeping units and each store could carry on average about 3,000 stock keeping units depending upon the local customer demand. Seven-Eleven emphasized regional merchandizing to cater precisely to local preferences. Each store carries food items, beverages, magazines, and consumer items such as soaps, detergents, etc.

The highest generated sale of Seven-Eleven is under food category, and under Seven-Eleven Japan concept, the food items were classified in four broad categories including Chilled items such as sandwiches, delicatessen products, and milk; Warm items such as box lunches, rice balls, and fresh bread; Frozen items such as ice-cream, frozen foods, and ice cubes; and Room-temperature items such as canned food, instant noodles, and seasonings. The efficiency in managing the inventory of Seven Eleven Japan could be proved by the resulted of inventory turnover rate is equal to over 50 when comparing to the second largest Seven Eleven in the United States is only about 17 in 2003.

For transportation or distribution system of Seven Eleven Japan, the system was tightly linked the entire supply chain for all product categories as Seven Eleven distribution centers and the information network played a key role in that regard. Its main objective is to carefully track sales of items and offer short replenishment cycle times. In 1987, Seven Eleven Japan had offered three times daily store delivery of all rice dishes and twice a day for fresh food. Its distribution system was flexible enough to alter delivery schedules depending on customer demand. When a store placed an order, it was immediately transmitted to the supplier as well as the distribution center. The supplier received orders from all Seven Eleven stores and started production to fill the orders. The supplier then sent the orders by truck to the distribution center. The key to store delivery was what Seven Eleven called the combined delivery system.

At the distribution center, delivery of like products from different suppliers was directed into a single temperature controlled truck. There were four categories of temperature-controlled trucks such as frozen foods, chilled food, room temperature processed foods, and warm foods. The number of stores per truck depended on the sales volume. The system worked on trust and did not require the delivery person to be present when the store personnel scanned in the delivery; this helps to reduce the delivery time spent at each store. Based on the information, it shown that Seven Eleven has continuously improve its transportation and distribution system, since 1974, there were 70 vehicles visited each store every day but later on in 1994, there were only 11 vehicles necessary. This dramatically reduced delivery costs and enabled rapid delivery of a variety of fresh foods. In 2004, Seven Eleven Japan had a total of 290 dedicated manufacturing plants throughout the country that only produced fast food for Seven Eleven stores. The items were distributed through 293 dedicated distribution centers that ensure rapid and reliable delivery. None of there distribution centers carried any inventory, they merely transferred inventory from supplier trucks to Seven Eleven distribution trucks. Transfleet Ltd., a company set up by Mitsui and Co. for exclusive use of Seven Eleven Japan, provided this transportation.

For information infrastructure, Seven Eleven Japan attributed a significant part of its success to the Total Information System installed in every outlet network linking the head office, stores, and the Seven Eleven distribution centers. Until July 1991, only a traditional analog network linked these chains. Later on, an integrated services digital network or ISDN was installed, linking more than 5,000 stores; it became one of the world’s largest ISDN system. This system enables Seven Eleven to collect, process, and feed back point of sales data quickly. Sales data generated in each stores by 11.00p.m., was processed and ready for analysis the next morning.

In 1997, Seven Eleven Japan was introduced its fifth generation of the Total Information System, which was still in use in 2004, the hardware system included as the following; Graphic Order Terminal, this was a handled device with a wide-screen graphic display, use by the store owner or manager to place the order. Once all the orders were placed, the terminal was returned to its slot, at which point the orders were relayed by the store computer to both the appropriate vendor and the Seven Eleven distribution center. Scanned Terminal, these scanners read bar codes and recorded inventory. They were used to receive product coming in from a distribution center. This was then automatically checked against a previously placed order and the two were reconciled. This scanner terminal was also used when examining inventory at stores.

Store Computer, this linked to the ISDN network, the POS register, the graphic order terminal, and the scanner terminal. It communicated between the various input sources, tracked store inventory and sales, places orders, provided detailed analysis of POS data, and maintained and regulated store equipment. POS register; this POS data was automatically transmitted online to a host computer. All sales data collected by 11.00p.m. was organized and ready for analysis by the next morning. The data was evaluated on a company wide, district, and store basis.

Due to Seven Eleven done in its choice of information infrastructure to develop capability that support its supply chain strategy, the information system allowed Seven Eleven store to better match supply with demand. Store staff could adjust the merchandising mix on the shelves according to consumption patterns throughout the day. The identification of slow and non-moving items also allowed a store to convert shelf space to introduce new items.

2. Seven-Eleven’s supply chain strategy in Japan can be described as attempting to micro-match supply and demand using rapid replenishment. What are some risks associated with this choice?

By using rapid replenishment system, Seven-Eleven Japan store can manage lower inventory in the store and higher shelf space available. This fit for Seven-Eleven in Japan because of smaller size of the store. But it still have some risk in case of a very fluctuated demand, when the demand raise to a very high level the inventory that the store stock might not be enough to serve customers demand. This situation will lead to loss of a sale and lower customer’s satisfaction.

The rapid replenishment is a core concept to lean thinking. It’s how you can manage the flow of inventory and how you can shorten the cycle time between each delivery. Which mean seven eleven will deliver more often and the quantity of the product between each deliver will depend on the demand of the customer that forecast from the Point Of Sale and previous Data. It allowed seven eleven to be able to control their inventory level because when they deliver more often they can deliver just few amounts at a time. Therefore there are also some risks associated with this system.

First, even though the rapid replenishment is a good system but the cost of replenishing and receiving is high. It’s because the system that require to put the rapid replenishment become efficient, for example they have to install the point of sale system to generate the sale information to the dc and supplier so they can deliver the good that fit for the curtain demand. For the receiving they also have to have the product scanner to scan the product when it arrives to the store. All of that equipment that’s required will raise the cost of the replenishing and receiving. Furthermore, the receiving cost also high because of the number of the delivery that higher too.

Second, even though rapid replenishment helps seven eleven to maintain their inventory level that drive by the demand of the customer, to save their inventory cost. Sometime it might be risk in the shorten of inventory(backlogs) because when seven eleven tried to micro match the demand and supply, seven eleven have to rely on the past purchasing data and the point of sale data. To be able to generate the demand forecast to deliver the product to each of seven eleven chain store. What if the demand has become so fluctuate to the point that it over their inventory level, that time seven eleven will be suffer from the empty shelf. As you know that the favorite items from seven eleven are such as lunchbox, rice ball and sandwich, so most likely if the consumer come during the high demand won’t have the food to consume. So most likely the consumer will go to other convenience store to buy the food to serve their need in that curtain time. If this scenario happen more that few time, the consumer most likely to switch the convenient store.

That’s why this is also the risk that seven eleven has to face and try to overcome in order to maintain their competitive advantage.

Third, the risk that they have to face is that they will not have the economics of scale in production because when they apply the rapid replenishment, the suppliers will only produce the product to match the need of the store when they need it. They won’t produce the same item for the large amount, which is if they produce in that way they won’t have to suffer from the set up cost in each batch that they have to produce.

Fourth, even though the rapid replenishment will lower the transportation but seven eleven still have to concern about the gas price because if the gas price raise it will again increase their operation cost. Then again seven eleven won’t be able to raise their product price to serve that cost too due to the incentive competition in the convenience market.

Fifth, Due to the system that when the trucks deliver the product to the store, there will be only the store people who scan and check the product in to the system. There will be no way of detecting the feud. The replenishment system worked on trust and did not require the delivery person to be present when the store personnel scanned in the delivery. This is a very risky system because store personnel may stoles the products. It can cause company loss in a million.

1. A convenience store chain attempts to be responsive and provide customers what they need, when they need it, where they need it. What are some different ways that a convenience store supply chain can be responsive? What are some risks in each case?

As responsiveness increases, the convenience store chain is exposed to greater uncertainty. A convenience store chain can improve responsiveness to this uncertainty using one of the following strategies, especially for fresh and fast foods:

1. Local Capacity. The convenience store chain can provide local cooking capacity at the stores and assemble foods almost on demand. Inventory would be stored as raw material. This is seen at the U.S. fast-food restaurant franchise Subway where dinner and lunch sandwiches are assembled on demand. The main risk with this approach is that capacity is decentralized, leading to poorer utilization.

2. Local Inventory Another approach is to have all inventory available at the store at all times. This allows for the centralization of cooking capacity. The main risk is obsolete inventory and the need for extra space.

3. Rapid Replenishment Another approach is to set up rapid replenishment and supply the stores with what they need when they need it. This allows for centralization of cooking capacity and low levels of inventory, but increases the cost of replenishment and receiving.

From the case study, Seven-eleven Japan Co. had provided their customers a variety of service that is difference responsive way from usual convenience store concept.

1. 7dream.com

Seven-Eleven Japan established an e-commerce company which their customer can choose the product at home and pick the product at the store. Because from the survey, 92% of its customers preferred to pick up their online purchase at the local convenience store rather than have them delivered at home. Since Seven-Eleven Japan have the distribution system that conforms with these drop and pick up system. So Seven-Eleven serve as drop-off and collection points for Japanese people. Instead of providing customers at that time the need is happen, the customers can choose the product at home and then pick up the product later at the store.  The risk of this case is normally Seven-Eleven Japan established this system as a way to derive benefit from the existing distribution system. If in the future this system is popular among the Japanese, the capacity of the existing distribution system may not be enough to serve the customers such as a space to storage the goods waiting for customers to pick up (the store in Japan is smaller than other country)

2. In-Store Payment

Instead of selling household goods, food and groceries, a convenience store can be responsive as a payment spot. Seven-Eleven Japan add a variety of services that customers can obtain at its stores for example an in-store payment of Tokyo Electric Power bills, gas, insurance premiums, and telephone. In order to attracted millions of additional customers every year and take advantage of opening hour and number of stores to service customer.

The risk of this case is when the company adopt this service every Seven-Eleven store Japan have to link with the data of the payment such as electric bill. If the employees not fully understand how the system works, he or she will misunderstand and take too long to serve customer. Result in lower customer satisfaction and can link to overall brand dissatisfaction. Some customer will stop buying at Seven-Eleven because the long waiting time.

1. Define Quality in Terms of Customers and   Their Requirements:

- Buyer must clearly quantify or specify requirements.

- Buyer must clearly communicate requirements through RFPs, negotiation process, and performance feedback sessions.

2. Pursue Quality at the Source:

- Cross-functional teams should visit and evaluate potential suppliers.
- Suppliers should be involved in the development stage of the buyer’s requirements.

3. Focus on objective rather than subjective analysis:

- Develop objective supplier measurements.

- Use data from measurements to award future business, identify performance improvement opportunities, and provide feedback and quality expectations to the supplier.

4. Emphasize Prevention Rather than Detection of Defects :

- Avoid nonconformance of products.
- Select suppliers that have systems, processes and methods in place to prevent defects.
- Use of supplier quality certifications and corrective action requests support prevention of defects.

5. Focus on process rather than output:

- Shift from a product to process orientation.
- Focus on the process that creates the output rather than the output.  If the process is correct, the output should be quality.
- Suppliers must provide evidence of process capability.

6. Strive for zero defects:

- Philip Crosby defines zero defects as conformance to requirements.
- Optimize your supply base to ensure capable suppliers.  Average supplier quality should increase as lower performers are eliminated.

7. Establish continuous improvement as a way of life:

- Shift performance targets upward once a supplier achieves current levels.
- Use Value Analysis to improve products and processes.
- Work to develop your supplier’s performance capabilities.

8. Make quality everyone’s responsibility:

- Buyers and sellers must assume ownership for total quality across the supply chain.
- Making quality each participant’s responsibility is essential for total supply chain quality.

Design changes can either add or remove sources of defects. Evolutionary design changes and simplification tend to remove defects, while revolutionary changes tend to increase them. On the other hand, occasionally revolutionary changes are required to avoid obsolescence.

Improved designs often require process changes. For example, new designs for electronic products require surface mount technology in manufacturing circuit boards, which in turn improve product reliability. Concurrent Engineering is a way to bring all of the functions involved in product development together.

Few professors will have the time to examine every available textbook alternative. A snappy cover can bring a favorable psychological impression so that the text receives further consideration, but the adoption decision is rooted in subject matter content. Fitness for use, support in the form of ancillary publications are important considerations. Since the prices of most popular texts are similar, value is not a significant factor in this decision.

Being able to reduce lead times gives a firm an important competitive advantage, given that customers value quick delivery. Time reduction resulted in higher market share and profit margins.

The distinctions between manufacturing and service organizations include the nature of the product, inventories, customer contact, response time, markets, facility size, capital intensity, and quality measurement. Organizations that do not fit the pattern are postal service and milk producer. Postal service as a service organization that fits many of the characteristics of a manufacturer, except that its output cannot be inventoried (for as extended period) and short response times are desirable. A milk producer who deals in local market cannot inventory the product for extended periods and has a perishable product.